Insights

When mediation makes sense, and when it doesn’t

Mediation can settle a dispute in weeks rather than years. It isn’t right for every case, though.

Edition

Going to court is slow, costly and public, and the result is decided by someone else. Mediation offers another route: the parties meet with a neutral mediator and work towards an agreement of their own.

When it works well

  • When the relationship matters. Parents who will co-parent for years, or business partners who share clients, often do better with an agreement they built themselves.
  • When the dispute is about more than money. Mediation can deal with practical arrangements that a court order cannot easily capture.
  • When both sides want it finished. Many mediations are completed in a few sessions.

When it may not be the right route

  • Where there is violence, abuse or a serious imbalance of power between the parties.
  • Where one party will not take part in good faith, or is hiding information.
  • Where an urgent court order is needed to protect someone or something.

What the courts expect

Since 2020, Rule 41A of the High Court’s Uniform Rules has asked parties to say, at the start of a case, whether they agree to refer the dispute to mediation, and why. Since July 2025 this applies to every new action or application (in urgent applications the court may excuse it). Even when a matter is already in court, it is not too late to try.

If you are unsure whether your dispute suits mediation, a short consultation can help you decide.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Speak to an attorney about your own circumstances.

All insights